PrepRung

CAT 2024 Slot 3 · VARC · Sentence Placement · hard

Deep-sea hydrothermal vents were discovered only in 1977, and their discovery overturned a basic assumption of biology. (1) Until then, virtually all…

Single correct option

Deep-sea hydrothermal vents were discovered only in 1977, and their discovery overturned a basic assumption of biology. (1) Until then, virtually all life on Earth was understood to depend, directly or indirectly, on sunlight, since photosynthesis sits at the base of nearly every known food chain. (2) The organisms clustered around the vents, however, derive their energy not from sunlight but from the oxidation of chemicals such as hydrogen sulphide spewed out by the vents themselves, a process called chemosynthesis. (3) Entire ecosystems, including giant tube worms, blind shrimp and unique species of crab, were found thriving in what had been presumed to be a lifeless abyss. (4) Astrobiologists now cite these vent ecosystems as a reason to take seriously the possibility of life on ice-covered moons such as Europa, which never receive sunlight at their ocean floors.

Where would the following sentence best fit?

'This single finding meant that scientists had to abandon the idea that sunlight was a strict prerequisite for life anywhere on Earth, let alone elsewhere in the universe.'
  1. A. Position (1)
  2. B. Position (2)
  3. C. Position (3)
  4. D. Position (4)
Show answer and solution

Answer: (D) Position (4)

The sentence generalises from the concrete discovery (chemosynthesis-based vent life, described just before position 4) to a broad implication about sunlight not being a strict prerequisite for life 'anywhere on Earth, let alone elsewhere in the universe.' This generalisation naturally follows the concrete detail about thriving vent ecosystems (sentence before position 4) and leads smoothly into the following sentence about astrobiologists and Europa. Placing it earlier, at (1) or (2), would state the conclusion before the supporting facts (chemosynthesis, thriving ecosystems) have been given.
Report a mistake

Original question written in the CAT 2024 Slot 3 pattern and checked twice for the correct answer. Not an official question paper. How we write and check questions · Corrections policy · Report a mistake