PrepRung

JEE Advanced 2020 Paper 1 · Physics · Fluid Mechanics, Elasticity and Surface Tension · medium

A wide open cylindrical tank of height H stands on level ground and is kept full of water up to its top. A small hole is drilled in its vertical wall…

One or more options correct

A wide open cylindrical tank of height HH stands on level ground and is kept full of water up to its top. A small hole is drilled in its vertical wall at a depth xx below the free surface, and the water emerges horizontally. Viscosity is negligible. Which of the following statements is/are correct?
  1. A. The horizontal ranges on the ground for holes at depths H/4H/4 and 3H/43H/4 are in the ratio 3:1\sqrt3:1.
  2. B. The time of flight of the water jet is the same for every hole in the wall.
  3. C. The maximum possible range of the jet is HH, and it is obtained from a hole at depth H/2H/2.
  4. D. The range of the jet from a hole at depth H/4H/4 is H/2H/2.
Show answer and solution

Answer: C

By Torricelli the exit speed is 2gx\sqrt{2gx}, and the water falls through height H−xH-x in time t=2(H−x)/gt=\sqrt{2(H-x)/g}, so the range is R=2x(H−x)R=2\sqrt{x(H-x)}. Option (A) is false: for x=H/4x=H/4 and x=3H/4x=3H/4 the product x(H−x)x(H-x) is the same (3H2/163H^2/16), so the ranges are equal (32H\frac{\sqrt3}{2}H each), ratio 1:11:1. Option (B) is false since the fall height H−xH-x depends on the hole. Option (C) is true: x(H−x)x(H-x) is maximum at x=H/2x=H/2, giving Rmax=2H2/4=HR_{max}=2\sqrt{H^2/4}=H. Option (D) is false because R(H/4)=32H≈0.87HR(H/4)=\frac{\sqrt3}{2}H\approx0.87H, not 0.5H0.5H. The tank is wide, so the surface level hardly changes, and Bernoulli's equation between the surface and the hole gives the exit speed. Symmetry of x(H−x)x(H-x) about H/2H/2 is the key to the whole question.
Report a mistake

Original question written in the JEE Advanced 2020 Paper 1 pattern and checked twice for the correct answer. Not an official question paper. How we write and check questions · Corrections policy · Report a mistake