PrepRung

CAT 2017 Slot 1 · DILR · Allocation and Selection · hard

CAT 2017 Slot 1 DILR: Project Team Formation

A company must form a five-member project team from nine employees: four engineers (A, B, C and D), three designers (E, F and G) and two analysts (H and I). The team must satisfy all of the following conditions:

1. It must include at least two engineers, at least one designer and at least one analyst.
2. A and E cannot both be in the team.
3. A and D cannot both be in the team.
4. F and I cannot both be in the team.
5. If B is in the team, then H must also be in the team.
6. C is in the team if and only if G is in the team.

Question 1

Numerical answer

How many different teams can be formed?
Show answer and solution

Answer: 13

Listing the valid teams. Split by whether C and G (who come as a pair) are included.

*With C and G:* three more members, with at least one more engineer and at least one analyst. Checking all cases gives 11 teams: ABCGH, ACFGH, ACGHI, BCDGH, BCEGH, BCFGH, BCGHI, CDEGH, CDEGI, CDFGH, CDGHI.

*Without C and G:* engineers come from A, B, D (A and D not together) and designers from E, F. With A: the other engineer must be B, so H is in; the designer cannot be E, so F, and then the fifth member... A, B, F, H plus one of D/E/I — all forbidden (A–D, A–E, F–I) ✗. Without A: B and D, so H is in; the fifth is from E, F, I: BDEFH and BDEHI (BDFHI violates F–I). That gives 2 teams.

Total = 11 + 2 = 13 teams.

Answer: 13.

Question 2

Single correct option

If I is in the team, how many different teams are possible?
  1. A. 3
  2. B. 4
  3. C. 5
  4. D. 6
Show answer and solution

Answer: (C) 5

Listing the valid teams. Split by whether C and G (who come as a pair) are included.

*With C and G:* three more members, with at least one more engineer and at least one analyst. Checking all cases gives 11 teams: ABCGH, ACFGH, ACGHI, BCDGH, BCEGH, BCFGH, BCGHI, CDEGH, CDEGI, CDFGH, CDGHI.

*Without C and G:* engineers come from A, B, D (A and D not together) and designers from E, F. With A: the other engineer must be B, so H is in; the designer cannot be E, so F, and then the fifth member... A, B, F, H plus one of D/E/I — all forbidden (A–D, A–E, F–I) ✗. Without A: B and D, so H is in; the fifth is from E, F, I: BDEFH and BDEHI (BDFHI violates F–I). That gives 2 teams.

Total = 11 + 2 = 13 teams.

Teams containing I: ACGHI, BCGHI, CDEGI, CDGHI, BDEHI → 5. (F can never appear with I.)

Question 3

Single correct option

If H is not in the team, which of the following must be true?
  1. A. B is in the team
  2. B. E is in the team
  3. C. F is in the team
  4. D. A is in the team
Show answer and solution

Answer: (B) E is in the team

Listing the valid teams. Split by whether C and G (who come as a pair) are included.

*With C and G:* three more members, with at least one more engineer and at least one analyst. Checking all cases gives 11 teams: ABCGH, ACFGH, ACGHI, BCDGH, BCEGH, BCFGH, BCGHI, CDEGH, CDEGI, CDFGH, CDGHI.

*Without C and G:* engineers come from A, B, D (A and D not together) and designers from E, F. With A: the other engineer must be B, so H is in; the designer cannot be E, so F, and then the fifth member... A, B, F, H plus one of D/E/I — all forbidden (A–D, A–E, F–I) ✗. Without A: B and D, so H is in; the fifth is from E, F, I: BDEFH and BDEHI (BDFHI violates F–I). That gives 2 teams.

Total = 11 + 2 = 13 teams.

Without H, the analyst must be I, so F is out and B is out (B needs H). The only valid team is C, D, E, G, I. Hence E is in the team must be true; A, B and F are all excluded.

Question 4

Single correct option

Which employee is a member of the largest number of possible teams?
  1. A. C
  2. B. G
  3. C. B
  4. D. H
Show answer and solution

Answer: (D) H

Listing the valid teams. Split by whether C and G (who come as a pair) are included.

*With C and G:* three more members, with at least one more engineer and at least one analyst. Checking all cases gives 11 teams: ABCGH, ACFGH, ACGHI, BCDGH, BCEGH, BCFGH, BCGHI, CDEGH, CDEGI, CDFGH, CDGHI.

*Without C and G:* engineers come from A, B, D (A and D not together) and designers from E, F. With A: the other engineer must be B, so H is in; the designer cannot be E, so F, and then the fifth member... A, B, F, H plus one of D/E/I — all forbidden (A–D, A–E, F–I) ✗. Without A: B and D, so H is in; the fifth is from E, F, I: BDEFH and BDEHI (BDFHI violates F–I). That gives 2 teams.

Total = 11 + 2 = 13 teams.

Counting appearances across the 13 teams: H is in 12 (every team except CDEGI), C and G are in 11 each, B and D in 7 each. So H appears most often.
Report a mistake

Original question written in the CAT 2017 Slot 1 pattern and checked twice for the correct answer. Not an official question paper. How we write and check questions · Corrections policy · Report a mistake