PrepRung

JEE Advanced 2022 Paper 2 · Physics · Atoms, Nuclei and Dual Nature of Radiation · medium

A photon of wavelength equal to the Compton wavelength λC=h/(mec) of the electron is scattered by a free electron initially at rest, through an angle…

Numerical answer

A photon of wavelength equal to the Compton wavelength λC=h/(mec)\lambda_C=h/(m_ec) of the electron is scattered by a free electron initially at rest, through an angle of 90∘90^\circ. Let φ\varphi be the angle that the recoiling electron's momentum makes with the direction of the incident photon. The value of cot⁡φ\cot\varphi is ______.
Show answer and solution

Answer: 2

Compton shift: λ′−λ=λC(1−cos⁡90∘)=λC\lambda'-\lambda=\lambda_C(1-\cos90^\circ)=\lambda_C, so λ′=2λC\lambda'=2\lambda_C. Photon momenta are p0=h/λC=mecp_0=h/\lambda_C=m_ec (incident) and p′=h/(2λC)=p0/2p'=h/(2\lambda_C)=p_0/2 (scattered, perpendicular to the incident direction). Conservation of momentum gives the electron momentum components: along the incident direction px=p0p_x=p_0, and perpendicular py=−p′=−p0/2p_y=-p'=-p_0/2 (opposite to the scattered photon). Then tan⁡φ=∣py∣/px=12\tan\varphi=|p_y|/p_x=\tfrac12, so cot⁡φ=2\cot\varphi=2. Consistency check with energy: the electron gains E0−E′=mec2−12mec2=12mec2E_0-E'=m_ec^2-\tfrac12m_ec^2=\tfrac12 m_ec^2, so Ee=1.5 mec2E_e=1.5\,m_ec^2; and pe2c2=p02c2 (1+14)=1.25 me2c4p_e^2c^2=p_0^2c^2\,(1+\tfrac14)=1.25\,m_e^2c^4, giving Ee2=me2c4+pe2c2=2.25 me2c4E_e^2=m_e^2c^4+p_e^2c^2=2.25\,m_e^2c^4, as required. The kinematics can also be seen from the vector triangle: the incident photon momentum p⃗0\vec p_0 equals the sum of the scattered photon momentum p⃗′\vec p' and the electron momentum p⃗e\vec p_e, so p⃗e=p⃗0−p⃗′\vec p_e=\vec p_0-\vec p' has magnitude p02+p′2=52p0\sqrt{p_0^2+p'^2}=\tfrac{\sqrt5}{2}p_0 and its direction is below the incident axis by arctan⁡(1/2)≈26.6∘\arctan(1/2)\approx26.6^\circ. Because the scattering angle is 90∘90^\circ the two photon momenta are perpendicular and no trigonometric ambiguity arises.
Report a mistake

Original question written in the JEE Advanced 2022 Paper 2 pattern and checked twice for the correct answer. Not an official question paper. How we write and check questions · Corrections policy · Report a mistake