PrepRung

JEE Advanced 2022 Paper 2 · Physics · Thermodynamics and Kinetic Theory of Gases · hard

One mole of a monatomic ideal gas is initially at pressure P0, volume V0 and temperature T0. It is taken to a volume 2V0 by three different…

One or more options correct

One mole of a monatomic ideal gas is initially at pressure P0P_0, volume V0V_0 and temperature T0T_0. It is taken to a volume 2V02V_0 by three different processes: (i) a reversible isothermal expansion, (ii) a reversible adiabatic expansion, (iii) a free expansion into vacuum inside a thermally insulated rigid container (the gas initially occupies half of it). Which of the following is/are correct?
  1. A. The work done by the gas in (ii) is greater than that in (i).
  2. B. The entropy change of the gas in (iii) is zero.
  3. C. The final pressure of the gas in (iii) equals that in (ii).
  4. D. The heat absorbed by the gas in (i) is greater than the work done by the gas in (ii).
Show answer and solution

Answer: D

With γ=5/3\gamma=5/3. (i) Wi=Qi=RT0ln⁡2≈0.693RT0W_i=Q_i=RT_0\ln2\approx0.693RT_0. (ii) Tf=T02−2/3T_f=T_02^{-2/3}, Wii=CV(T0−Tf)=1.5RT0(1−2−2/3)≈0.555RT0W_{ii}=C_V(T_0-T_f)=1.5RT_0(1-2^{-2/3})\approx0.555RT_0 and Pf=P02−5/3≈0.315P0P_f=P_02^{-5/3}\approx0.315P_0. (iii) No work, no heat, so ΔU=0\Delta U=0, Tf=T0T_f=T_0 and Pf=P0/2P_f=P_0/2. (A) is incorrect: 0.555RT0<0.693RT00.555RT_0<0.693RT_0 (the isothermal curve lies above the adiabat, so it encloses more area). (B) is incorrect: free expansion is irreversible and ΔS=Rln⁡2>0\Delta S=R\ln2>0 (compute along a reversible isothermal path between the same end states). (C) is incorrect: 0.5P0≠0.315P00.5P_0\ne0.315P_0. (D) is correct: Qi≈0.693RT0>Wii≈0.555RT0Q_i\approx0.693RT_0>W_{ii}\approx0.555RT_0. Remember that the entropy change must be evaluated along a reversible path connecting the same end states, which for an ideal gas in free expansion is an isothermal expansion, giving ΔS=Rln⁡2\Delta S=R\ln2. The adiabat in a PP-VV diagram falls more steeply than the isotherm, which is why both its final pressure and its work are smaller than the isothermal values, and why (iii) ends at a pressure between the two.
Report a mistake

Original question written in the JEE Advanced 2022 Paper 2 pattern and checked twice for the correct answer. Not an official question paper. How we write and check questions · Corrections policy · Report a mistake