PrepRung

JEE Advanced 2018 Paper 1 · Physics · Rotational Motion · medium

A solid uniform sphere and a thin uniform hollow spherical shell have equal masses and equal radii. Both are released from rest, from the same…

One or more options correct

A solid uniform sphere and a thin uniform hollow spherical shell have equal masses and equal radii. Both are released from rest, from the same vertical height hh, at the top of the same rough incline of angle θ\theta. The incline is rough enough that both roll without slipping. Which of the following statements is/are correct?
  1. A. Both bodies reach the bottom with the same centre-of-mass speed.
  2. B. The solid sphere reaches the bottom earlier than the shell.
  3. C. The magnitude of the friction force on the shell is greater than that on the solid sphere.
  4. D. The minimum coefficient of friction needed for pure rolling is greater for the solid sphere than for the shell.
Show answer and solution

Answer: B, C

Write the rolling condition with I=kmR2I=kmR^2: a=gsin⁡θ1+ka=\dfrac{g\sin\theta}{1+k}, friction f=k1+kmgsin⁡θf=\dfrac{k}{1+k}mg\sin\theta and v2=2gh1+kv^2=\dfrac{2gh}{1+k}. For the solid sphere k=2/5k=2/5, giving a=57gsin⁡θa=\tfrac57 g\sin\theta and f=27mgsin⁡θf=\tfrac27 mg\sin\theta. For the shell k=2/3k=2/3, giving a=35gsin⁡θa=\tfrac35 g\sin\theta and f=25mgsin⁡θf=\tfrac25 mg\sin\theta. (A) is false because v2=107ghv^2=\tfrac{10}{7}gh for the sphere but 65gh\tfrac65 gh for the shell. (B) is true: the sphere has the larger acceleration over the same distance, so it takes less time. (C) is true since 25>27\tfrac25>\tfrac27. (D) is false: the requirement is μ≥k1+ktan⁡θ\mu\ge \dfrac{k}{1+k}\tan\theta, which is larger for the shell, not the sphere.
Report a mistake

Original question written in the JEE Advanced 2018 Paper 1 pattern and checked twice for the correct answer. Not an official question paper. How we write and check questions · Corrections policy · Report a mistake